117 NE 5th St e, McMinnville, OR 97128 (503) 437-3391 office@brehancrawford.com

Diagnosing Lyme Disease

Tick on fingertip -- nymphs can be even smaller than this

How do I know if I have Lyme Disease?

This is a common question I get from patients and other practitioners I’m training.

The truth is that outside of a few specific examples which we’ll cover here, it can be difficult to get a concrete diagnosis for Lyme. I know, not what you were hoping to hear. But even if the diagnosis is difficult to obtain, there may still be strong hope for complete recovery.

Please read on and contact us with your questions.

1) Acute exposure with certainty.

If you find a tick bite, you develop an erythema migrans rash (aka target lesion or bull’s-eye rash), and you get flu-like symptoms without any respiratory involvement (fever, malaise, joint pain, especially one-sided knee pain, digestive upset especially diarrhea), you can bet you’ve got acute Lyme disease. We call this a clinical diagnosis. No testing is generally necessary and it’s best to begin treatment as quickly as possible.

As terrible as it sounds, if you’re going to get Lyme this is the best-case scenario because your diagnosis is clear and the treatment is simple. Go to your primary care provider and get on a 21-day course of antibiotics.  Finish the course. Get lots of sleep, reduce your stress level for this period of time, and take generally good care of yourself — eat healthy, simple foods, get gentle exercise, surround yourself with your closest friends and family.

Like most medicine this treatment isn’t perfect, and the antibiotics can be rough, but it’s very effective for acute Lyme and if it can save you from requiring long-term treatment to put chronic Lyme in remission it’s probably worth the discomfort.  If the antibiotics are really messing with your system, or afterwards you just don’t feel like yourself quite yet, seek help from a skilled Chinese medical herbalist.  You can also take Chinese herbal medicine at the same time as the antibiotics and there is some evidence that this makes the antibiotics more effective — multiple vectors of antimicrobial action reduce the likelihood of antibiotic resistance and adaptive behavior by infectious agents; herbs can effectively dissolve biofilms and make it harder for the bacteria to “hide;” and many Chinese herbs and formulas are neuroprotective and can help prevent Borrelia from entering the central nervous system where antibiotics are less likely to work. (1) (2)

When the course of antibiotics is completed, you’ll likely — but not always — be cured of Lyme. If the symptoms persist, see a practitioner who knows how to treat your presentation and understands your history; with luck and a little time you’ll be yourself again.

2) Acute exposure without certainty.

Two possibilities here: either you find a tick bite but have no signs or symptoms of infection, or you have an erythema migrans rash and flu-like symptoms without respiratory involvement, but you never found a tick.

If you’re in the first scenario: conservative measures are best. Not all ticks carry Borrelia, the bacteria that causes Lyme, and although there are reports to the contrary in most cases of Lyme disease the tick must be on the body for 24 hours to transmit Borrelia. Coinfections which are also transmitted by ticks may not take quite as long but in the absence of Borrelia they are much simpler to treat and may not cause health concerns as severe.

You can send the tick off to a lab to have it tested for Borrelia, but again if it was not on your body for 24 hours it’s less likely that would have been transmitted to you.

If you’re in the second scenario: first ask yourself what you’ve been doing in the last week. Have you been anywhere that a tick bite is likely — Hiking? Camping? Gardening? Have you been in any grassy areas, especially areas where tall grasses are on the edge of a wooded area?  Ticks, especially in their nymph stage (the most likely stage of life for them to carry Borrelia), can be incredibly hard to detect as they are only 2mm in size, smaller than a poppy seed.

Lab testing for Lyme disease is not yet a mature science. You can get an IGM Western Blot test from your primary care provider but these are not 100% accurate and have a high rate of false negative findings.  Nonetheless, if you’re showing all of the symptoms of an acute infection and you’ve recently been spending a lot of time outdoors, there is a good chance you’ve contracted Borrelia and should take appropriate measures.  A 21-day course of antibiotics may not be inappropriate and it’s worth having a conversation with your primary care provider to see if that’s right for you. If you’re averse to using antibiotics, especially without a concrete diagnosis, you can use constitutionally appropriate Chinese Herbal medicine. Make an appointment with an experienced practitioner and there is a good chance you’ll get out of things okay.

3) Chronic exposure with certainty.

If you recall a tick bite, an erythema migrans rash, and you now have symptoms of chronic Lyme disease or “Post Lyme Disease Syndrome” (the accuracy and use of these terms is hotly debated), you almost certainly have had exposure in the past which is now causing your symptoms. This must be treated by a skilled professional. Many “Lyme-literate” physicians will utilize prolonged cocktails of multiple rotating antibiotics despite evidence contrary to the efficacy of such methods and the harsh side-effects they have on the body. Treating these cases as Gu syndrome as outlined by my mentor Heiner Fruehauf  is largely effective, though it can take a considerable amount of time.  Consult a practitioner with training and experience in this area please.

4) Chronic exposure without certainty.

This is again an area in which the science of biomedical diagnosis is not yet mature. Many tests are available which claim to have differing degrees of accuracy but only a few are actually helpful. I’ll outline those here:

IGG Western Blot: 5 positive bands are required to report a case of Lyme to public health authorities. In my clinical experience, this threshold is too high and ignores many cases of persistent infection. If patients present with history and symptoms of likely exposure to Borrelia and confections, and have even one positive band on this test, I generally recommend an initial course of diagnostic treatment with Chinese herbal medicine. The risks involved with treatment are low and if the symptoms improve or a Herxheimer-like reaction appears, we can make a clinical diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease.

CD57: The utility of this test is somewhat controversial. The CD57 test is not specific to Lyme as there are other possible reasons that a count on this test could be low.  However, as Gu treatment is not specific to Lyme either, I find that having patients get this test at the beginning of treatment can be helpful so they can see an objective measurement of improvement as they heal.

A note on ordering labs: in the state of Oregon my license does not permit me to order labs on behalf of my patients; so I always refer to other types of providers who can do this. Some patients have found ways to order labs themselves; I recommend going through a licensed provider who can help you interpret the test results.

If you are in this category this can be a frustrating and nebulous affair. Many patients with symptoms but no clear diagnosis have a difficult time finding effective treatment and bounce from provider to provider looking for answers.  Making sense of the different attitudes towards the existence of chronic Lyme disease, the diagnostic criteria required to name it as such and the treatment methodology can be daunting and exhausting.

Summing up.

I hope these guidelines are helpful. As a piece of commentary I will add that the vast majority of patients with chronic Lyme I treat have a clinical diagnosis.  They are either in category 3 from above (tick bite with rash) but did not receive treatment with antibiotics timely enough for it to be effective or were not treated at all, or in category 4: chronic insidious onset of complex and changing symptoms which wax and wane but become worse over time and are hard to diagnose but show a positive response to treatment as Gu syndrome.

One final word on coinfections: Lyme is considered a “polymicrobial” disease — it is a syndrome tied particularly to different strains of Borrelia but also frequently involves other bacteria, molds, viruses and even parasites. Extensive (and expensive) testing can be done to identify the specific microbes involved in each patients’ case; many of these tests are also not mature in their accuracty and speaking from clinical experience once we have a diagnosis of Borrelia and begin treating as Gu syndrome, we always assume the presence of multiple different infectious agents and treat the patient as such.

If you have questions about the information presented in this blog post please Contact my office.

To your health,

Brehan Crawford

This Post Has 9 Comments

  1. Nice article, Brehan. My wife and I recently got a PANDAS diagnosis for our eight year old daughter (ruled out Lyme). Treating her with Augmentin and about to initiate Classical Pearls. We shall see. A very challenging case, my little girl.

    1. Thank you Martin. Hope all goes well for your daughter.

  2. Hi Brehen,

    Hey, I hear over and over by Oregon patients that both primary care doctors and infectious disease doctors are turning concerned patients away for care. Patients come in with flu like symptoms and are concerned they may have been bitten or may have contracted Lyme and they are dismissed. These docs still believe (are taught) that Lyme doesn’t exist in Oregon nor do they believe that Lyme can become chronic. I have yet to hear of a primary in Oregon willing to prescribe the short course of Doxycyline that is required to fully eracticate an acute case. This is sad indeed because if/when these people believe their trusted primary doctor and don’t receive prompt care, they risk the infection becoming chronic which is much more difficult to treat and can make a patient sick long-term. I understand Oregon to be the most difficult state to receive adequate care due to legislature. Theresa, who is head of the Oregon Lyme Disease Network helps patients all across Oregon navigate these difficult circumstances and find the right doctors that will listen and prescribe. Generally, this means seeing an ILADS trained doctor, called a LLND, a “Lyme Literate Naturopath”. My understanding is, this has become a must because MD’s aren’t allowed to treat Lyme in this state. They could risk their license? (Primary’s are generally MD’s). What do you know about this Dr Brehen? There are multiple LLND’s in Oregon who can and are willing to treat an acute case with a short course of antibiotics. Problem is, it takes a lot of digging and connections to find these doctors. Many drives far to receive care. I pray someday soon, Oregon legislature will better support it’s lyme patients.

    http://www.ilads.org is a very helpful website for those new to lyme and even has software to find lyme literate doctors in all states.

    1. Hi Tammy, thanks for your comment.

      It’s a sad but accurate statement that many primary care providers in Oregon are not aware that patients can contract Lyme here; and that those patients are not treated correctly during the brief window where antibiotics are largely effective and Lyme can be said to be cured. More continuing education and practitioner outreach in this area is certainly needed. Lyme is definitely here and with the climate warming we will only see more of it.

      I don’t know about the legislative hurdles you mention. Since I’m not an MD or considered primary care I’m under a different scope of practice; I know that many NDs do use antibiotics to treat acute Lyme and they are considered primary care in Oregon but also have a different licensing board than MDs/DOs which may be more flexible. But certainly access to NDs, especially those NDs who are willing to prescribe antibiotics, is less than other primary care providers.

  3. Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and I find
    It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give something back and aid others like you helped me.

  4. Right here is the right blog for everyone who wants
    to understand this topic. You understand a whole
    lot its almost hard to argue with you (not that I personally will need to…HaHa).

    You certainly put a fresh spin on a topic which has
    been discussed for a long time. Wonderful stuff,
    just excellent!

  5. Excellent overview of a bad situation where clinicians have their hands tied by the IDSA and CDC in respect of diagnosing borrelia before treatment (evidence based medicine) in USA and Canada and it seems many other places in the world. I am just coming up to one year infected and feel like crap with upper torso pain, neck, headaches and exhaustion. Seeking a solution seems so hard and I am an evidence based patient lol

    1. Sorry you have had a tough time finding a solution. Our clinic works with patients in Oregon and from around the world; you can get in touch with us via the contact page to set up a consultation. https://brehancrawford.com/contact

Leave a Reply

Close Panel